Our shuttle to Connecticut’s pizza paradise was once inevitable after we discovered that New Haven is an insignificant 80 miles from New York Town. Whilst that distance could have been daunting a century in the past, it’s simply conquered lately in a couple of alternative ways – automotive, Amtrak and Metro North.
Two days was once simply sufficient time for us to pattern quite a few pizzas on the most renowned New Haven pizza stores. We incessantly ordered greater than shall we devour even with the help of our intrepid buddies Matt and Marie who sacrificed their stomachs for our noble quest.
In combination, we ate clam pizzas crowned with bacon, tomato and mozzarella pies, absolutely loaded pies and the granddaddy of New Haven pizza – apparently easy tomato pies.
New Haven wasn’t our first pizza rodeo. We’ve logged as regards to two months in Napoli over 3 separate journeys. We’ve eaten what’s most probably the sector’s easiest pizza in Caiazzo in addition to nice pies in Rome, Bologna, Verona and all 5 NYC boroughs.
In Naples, pizzas are notable for his or her airiness, suppleness and elements grown within the shadow of Mount Vesuvius. The New York pizza scene is extra about slice stores, prime quality toppings and massive bubbly crusts. Rome has two major pizza kinds – skinny and crispy Pizza Romana and bakery-style Pizza al Taglio which is incessantly incessantly minimize to reserve.
This was once our first foray with New Haven pizza. We knew it was once its personal factor when a chatty server criticized a competitor’s pizza for its ‘floppiness’ – it appears a mortal sin within the Connecticut pizza global.
So what did we take into consideration the pizza in New Haven?
In our moderately trained critiques, we predict that New Haven has a novel genre and position within the dynamic pizza global. Its pies have fun crunch and raise. Plus, we dig the sauciness in addition to the original collection of toppings presented on the town’s other pizzerias.
Those are our favourite New Haven pizza stores and those you shouldn’t pass over:
1. Sally’s Apizza
Whilst Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana would be the first forestall on our New Haven pizza move slowly, Sally’s Apizza will get the nod as our favourite New Haven pizza store. It’s now not that Frank Pepe isn’t superb – we simply loved our pizza enjoy at Sally’s Apizza a bit bit extra. Plus, we have now a factor for pizzerias with a just right backstory.
Salvatore Consiglio, often referred to as Sally, was once no newbie when he took the reins at his circle of relatives’s pizza store in 1938. His mom Filomena was once concerned as was once his brother Tony who had relationships with numerous A-list celebrities, in all probability explaining why Frank Sinatra, John F. Kennedy, Jody Foster and Paul Simon have all eaten pizza at Sally’s Apizza through the years.
Right here’s the place issues get attention-grabbing. Sally discovered the pizza ropes from his uncle Frank. Sure, Frank Pepe was once Sally’s uncle and the prolonged circle of relatives’s two pizzerias are situated at the identical block.
Our consult with at Sally’s Apizza began with a nice 30 minutes wait in an out of doors lot that’s been repurposed right into a ready house replete with wine and beer served on faucet. Alternatively, the true display began after we entered the ancient wood-paneled room that’s crowned with imitation Tiffany lamps, each and every emblazoned with the phrase ‘pizza’ and adorned with little males flipping pizza pies.
Talking of pies, we ordered 4 of them at Sally’s Apizza – two vintage New Haven pies (a Tomato Sauce Pie and a Mozzarella and Tomato Sauce Pie) and two area of expertise pies (a Contemporary Tomato White Pie and a Potato & Rosemary Particular). We later regretted now not ordering a clam pie. We’ll order one subsequent time.
To us, Sally Apizza’s Mozzarella and Tomato Pie pie is what separates this store from its neighbors. Regardless that very similar to a undeniable pizza, Sally’s model is a ways from undeniable with nice pizza sauce and simply the correct amount of cheese.
As we lifted the wedge-sized slices off its steel sheet tray, we famous that they didn’t flop. Similarly essential, the pizza had a pleasant crunch and, whilst darkish brown, its edges weren’t burned.
Whilst this Tomato Sauce pie was once cast with the equivalent attributes, we appreciated the only at Frank Pepe much more extra. In all probability Sally’s Apizza misplaced the threshold via sprinkling their pie with Parmigiano as a substitute of extra biting Pecorino Romano.
Past the classics, we particularly loved Sally’s Contemporary Tomato White Pie. The tanginess of its contemporary tomato slices contrasted the cooked elements used within the pizzeria’s extra vintage pizzas. Olive oil equipped a wealthy end.
Professional Tip
Save room for a slice of Cannoli Pie. Stuffed with candy cannoli cream and crowned with powered sugar, cocoa powder and chocolate chips, this luscious pie tasted like a dream and led to us to quickly overlook about our pizza project.
The unique Sally’s Apizza is situated at 237 Wooster Boulevard, New Haven, CT 06511, United States. The pizzeria is lately increasing inside Connecticut and in Massachusetts.
