Disney’s Yacht & Seaside Membership Lodges are sister inns positioned throughout Crescent Lake from the BoardWalk at Walt Disney International, each inside strolling distance of EPCOT and Hollywood Studios. This head-to-head comparability weighs professionals & cons of each and every, choosing a “winner” in theme, surroundings, rooms, eating, transportation, location and extra.
This continues our Walt Disney International Resort Comparability Collection, which incorporates a number of different tough dilemmas it’s possible you’ll face when attempting to pick out a resort. Different as opposed to posts come with Animal Kingdom Resort vs. Barren region Resort, Port Orleans Riverside vs. French Quarter, Caribbean Seaside vs. the Poly, and many others.
Maximum notable from the viewpoint of this put up: Seaside Membership vs. BoardWalk Inn and Seaside Membership vs. Swan & Dolphin. Even supposing the ones center of attention on Seaside Membership, this trio of posts must jointly will let you decide which Crescent Lake Lodge is for you. Work out which resort wins right here, after which transfer directly to the BoardWalk and Swolphin H2Hs, whether or not both of the ‘golf equipment’ are rather interchangeable for the needs of the ones comparisons.
The rationale we’re evaluating the Yacht & Seaside Membership in spite of them being so an identical is to offer somewhat extra perception into the upsides and drawbacks of each and every. Truthfully, our Ratings of ALL Walt Disney International Resorts from Worst to Very best don’t do complete justice to Yacht Membership. We took the straightforward course there, score it less than we would possibly differently as a result of Seaside Membership is the simpler possibility for first-timers.
In truth, Yacht and Seaside Membership are sister hotels which are bodily hooked up to each other, however this doesn’t imply they must be seen as a couple. Debunking this “fable” of types is principally our primary motivation for penning this comparability. In equity, their interchangeably does practice in some regards, reminiscent of transportation, eating, and facilities; when it comes to theme, rooms, and in different regards, they’re stark contrasts.
While you keep in a Walt Disney International lodge resort, you’re paying an important top class over an actual international venue, and that’s in large part for a couple of issues: location, rooms, and themed design. For the reason that, we expect opting for a lodge with surroundings that appeals to you is extremely essential.
Environment apart the overall ‘nautical-ness’ of each and every lodge, the theme and atmosphere of Yacht Membership and Seaside Membership and important departures from one any other. If anything else, Seaside Membership is extra similar to BoardWalk Inn from an atmospheric viewpoint, while Yacht Membership is (arguably) extra like a nautical Grand Floridian. Or most likely nearer to the 4 Seasons or any other real-world luxurious resort.
Suffice to mention, the lodge theme (and through extension, the room theme) must be an important deciding issue on this showdown. As such, the primary two variables on this Walt Disney International resort comparisons. Not like our different entries into this sequence, we don’t use all six components of 2 other hotels to decide which is “the most productive.” In reality, this comparability seeks much less to crown a definitive champion and extra to match and distinction.
Theme/Surroundings: It Is dependent
Whilst technically sister hotels, the theme and tone of each and every lodge is dramatically other. Seaside Membership has a theme as a result of former Disney CEO Michael Eisner’s obsession together with his early life holidays within the seashore communities of the Northeast. Its theme is supposed to awaken the seashore lodge cottages scattered round New England within the early twentieth Century.
Seaside Membership may be very laid again; each within the substance of the theme, and the types used. There are numerous gentle colours and pastels, and this makes for a calming atmosphere. The one factor relatively at-odds with that is that the foyer is on occasion noisy and chaotic, extra so than the Yacht Membership foyer. All issues regarded as, despite the fact that, I’d say Seaside Membership stocks extra with BoardWalk Inn when it comes to theme and surroundings than it does with Yacht Membership.
In contrast, Yacht Membership looks like a real high-society yachting membership set in flip of the century New England. If I have been to explain it in one phrase, I’d name it “stately.” The colour scheme is a lot more muted and darker, and there’s additionally an abundance of deep woods, nautically-themed antiques, and wealthy furnishings right through the lodge. The surroundings may move for a spot the place the Kennedys and different elites would possibly have met for liquid lunches and made energy performs.
This atmosphere may also be off-putting for some households. The only phrase we pay attention maximum steadily in terms of complaint of Yacht Membership is “stuffy.” Whilst we expect it stops properly in need of being stuffy or unfriendly to households, it’s undoubtedly extra refined and not more laid again.
Whilst the detractors view Yacht Membership as stuffy, the argument may simply as simply be made that it’s extra refined and delicate. That as an alternative of the sunshine and breezy surroundings of Seaside Membership, you’re getting one thing extra mature, like an actual international luxurious resort–and a glance that’s commensurate with the fee. We’ve spent numerous time in coastal California, and lots of the greatest oceanfront inns there are an identical in vibe to Yacht Membership.
Our take is that either one of those hotels be offering outstanding consideration to element and do an improbable task of conveying their respective subject matters, and atmosphere a tone for the lodge by way of the ones subject matters. Which is “higher” will in large part be an issue of private choice–whether or not you like delicate or laid again. Both one could have great holiday vibes that provide a pleasant distinction to the chaos of the parks; all of it depends upon what you in finding calming.
Rooms: Yacht Membership
That is a lot more straightforward. Each hotels not too long ago finished room refurbishments, changing some rather dated rooms for extra trendy ones. The outcome at Yacht Membership is dramatically awesome. The room extra well-appointed, with on-theme design components, pops of colour, and various Disney main points, addressing earlier complaint. See Assessment: Subtle Redone Rooms at Walt Disney International’s Maximum Subtle Lodge.
Seaside Membership’s new rooms are great, however bland. The hot room refurbishment there got rid of the carpet and added Donald Duck paintings, however didn’t move some distance sufficient in addressing visitor issues. Higher than they have been ahead of, however they nonetheless remind us of relatively Disneyfied mid-grade chain resort rooms you’ll find just about any place, aside from with a mild seashore motif.
They aren’t essentially dangerous, however really feel uninspired to us, and a few of the weakest of the redone rooms. No longer somewhat what we think given the fee issues of Seaside Membership. (The Seaside Membership Villa rooms are higher, however this isn’t a DVC comparability.)
With that mentioned, each units of rooms are very a lot an extension of the manner in their hotels. In case you in finding the foyer of Yacht Membership ‘stuffy and drab’ you’ll really feel the similar means in regards to the visitor rooms. In case you benefit from the ‘gentle and ethereal’ nature of Seaside Membership, you’ll in finding that prolonged into the visitor rooms.
Transportation/Location: Push
It is a in reality deficient foundation for opting for between the 2, however Seaside Membership is relatively nearer to the World Gateway front of EPCOT. This additionally makes it nearer to the Skyliner station, which provides get admission to to a number of inns plus Disney’s Hollywood Studios.
Alternatively, Yacht Membership is nearer to Disney’s Hollywood Studios. Even supposing fewer visitors stroll to DHS than EPCOT, that is the optimum manner for reliably attending to the park quickest. (We’ve “raced” and toes carry out higher over the years than the boats; Skyliner virtually by no means wins.)
Then again, we’re speaking a couple of minute distinction for each EPCOT and Disney’s Hollywood Studios, at maximum. It additionally depends upon the place your room is positioned, as each inns have interminably hallways that may exceed the gap to the park. Slight exaggeration, however on occasion it feels that means.
Relating to boat transportation, the 2 are equivalent as they percentage a ship dock. They’re additionally equivalent for bus transportation, with shared buses. We don’t suggest any individual choose from Seaside Membership and Yacht Membership at the foundation of location. The variation nets out to just about not anything in any respect until you’re doing EPCOT or DHS greater than the opposite.
Facilities: Push
That is in large part about eating and swimming pools, which can be most often separate classes. Since all swimming pools and eating places are shared between those two sister houses, there is not any significant difference between any of those.
With that mentioned, it’s at all times price noting that Stormalong Bay is superior, and is a superb foundation for opting for both (or each!) of those hotels. Stormalong Bay is the gold usual of Walt Disney International swimming pools. This sprawling pool complicated 3 acres in dimension with sand on the backside, a lazy river, delightful lounging area, and 230-foot water slide is in a league of its personal. This is likely one of the highest facilities in all of Walt Disney International.
Conversely, all Crescent Lake hotels (now not simply Y&BC, but additionally BoardWalk and Swolphin) have pathetic counter provider alternatives. Moreover, all the eating places right through Crescent Lake are so extremely simple to get admission to from one any other that we don’t assume eating is an outcome-determinative issue for any of those inns.
Value: Push
Usual room charges are an identical (properly, on occasion there’s like a $10 distinction–nevertheless it cuts each tactics), with upper tiers seeing some variations.
The result determinative issue this is reductions, and the ones are variable. Yacht Membership is one among Walt Disney International’s main conference inns, and when it’s internet hosting an tournament, particular provides are scarce. Conversely, it has a tendency to be relatively much less fashionable than Seaside Membership at different instances, and we’ve discovered each more straightforward availability and higher reductions. However that is very a lot YMMV.
Even supposing past the scope of this comparability, it’s price noting that Seaside Membership has a Disney Holiday Membership wing while Yacht Membership does now not. In case you’re renting DVC issues to economize, the one viable possibility this is the Seaside Membership Villas.
Verdict: It Is dependent
It’s inconceivable to crown a winner from an function viewpoint. In our enjoy, first-timers and rare guests have traditionally most well-liked Seaside Membership. However now not everybody does, and the foundation for that just about fully boils right down to surroundings–extra folks who prefer the sunshine and ethereal atmosphere of Seaside Membership than the stately and complex taste of Yacht Membership. All of that is purely subjective, clearly. We can not say one executes its theme higher than the opposite.
From an function viewpoint, the issue is twofold. First, those hotels percentage such a lot of facilities that it’s downright inconceivable to crown one victorious with out splicing them down the center and best counting the ones places bodily inside each and every lodge. That’s a nonsensical manner given the shared grounds, and the truth that some rooms in Yacht Membership is also further from that lodge’s facilities than some Seaside Membership rooms (and vice-a-versa).
In reality, the one component of the 2 hotels the place there’s a decisive merit is when it comes to room high quality, the place Yacht Membership prevails. Then again, even there, we’ve encountered numerous individuals who choose the brand new rooms at Seaside Membership as a result of their vibe and surroundings. So as soon as once more, even that will in large part be made up our minds through subjectivity.
Some of the causes we’ve revisited this subject is since the hole has closed in Walt Disney International fan perceptions of Yacht & Seaside Membership. After we first did this comparability a number of years in the past, we polled readers and Seaside Membership used to be the decisive winner–64% to 36%. We’ve redone that ballot, and right here’s the place issues these days stand:
Bearing in mind theme, surroundings & rooms (the remainder is shared), which of those two Walt Disney International inns do you like:
— Disney Vacationer Weblog (@DisTouristBlog) December 19, 2025
Neck and neck, in reality reinforcing the “It Is dependent” verdict right here. We’d notice that the one main adjustments since we remaining performed the ballot are the room refreshes and slight updates to the respective lobbies.
So it will appear that that is in large part a referendum at the new rooms, reinforcing what we wrote above that Walt Disney International did a nicer task with Yacht Membership.
In the long run, you in reality can’t move improper both means with Yacht or Seaside Membership. And that’s even with the dramatically other atmospheres and rooms. We in reality revel in each, and assume that the sister inns are nice compliments to each other. The genuine difference-maker this is Stormalong Bay, which supplies each the brink over many different Deluxe Lodges at Walt Disney International. Learn our complete Disney’s Yacht Membership Assessment and Disney’s Seaside Membership Assessment to peer extra footage of each and every, which is able to assist decide which is able to enchantment extra to you.
Making plans a Walt Disney International commute? Know about inns on our Walt Disney International Resorts Evaluations web page. For the place to devour, learn our Walt Disney International Eating place Evaluations. To economize on tickets or decide which kind to shop for, learn our Guidelines for Saving Cash on Walt Disney International Tickets put up. Our What to Pack for Disney Journeys put up takes a novel take a look at suave pieces to take. For what to do and when to do it, our Walt Disney International Experience Guides will assist. For complete recommendation, the most productive position to begin is our Walt Disney International Shuttle Making plans Information for the whole lot you want to understand!
Your Ideas
Which lodge do you like, Yacht Membership or Seaside Membership? Some other issues we didn’t bear in mind? Do you compromise or disagree with our verdict? Any questions we will be able to will let you solution about those inns? Listening to comments about your reports is each fascinating to us and useful to different readers, so please percentage your ideas underneath within the feedback!
Get our unfastened e-newsletter!
Join information, Disney offers & unfastened making plans guidelines
